Shark Teeth-Myakka City, FL. Relic Reef, Shark Teeth & Mystery Buckets

Your Own Dig At Home!

Mystery Shark Tooth Bucket (32 oz)

Sale

Mystery Shark Tooth Bucket (32 oz)

Regular price $39.99 USD

Regular price ~~$75.00 USD~~ Sale price $39.99 USD

Sale
MEGALODON MYSTERY BUCKETS! (32oz)

Sale

MEGALODON MYSTERY BUCKETS! (32oz)

Regular price $89.99 USD

Regular price ~~$120.00 USD~~ Sale price $89.99 USD

Sale
HASTALIS MYSTERY BUCKETS! (32oz)

Sale

HASTALIS MYSTERY BUCKETS! (32oz)

Regular price $79.99 USD

Regular price ~~$120.00 USD~~ Sale price $79.99 USD

Sale
Lil’ Chompers Shark Tooth Mystery Bucket - Kids Fossil Discovery Box

Sale

Lil’ Chompers Shark Tooth Mystery Bucket - Kids Fossil Discovery Box

Regular price $24.99 USD

Regular price ~~$34.99 USD~~ Sale price $24.99 USD

Sale
PREMIUM MEG MYSTERY BUCKET! (32 oz)

Sold out

PREMIUM MEG MYSTERY BUCKET! (32 oz)

Regular price $139.99 USD

Regular price ~~$179.99 USD~~ Sale price $139.99 USD

Sold out
PREMIUM HASTALIS MYSTERY BUCKET!

Sale

PREMIUM HASTALIS MYSTERY BUCKET!

Regular price $129.99 USD

Regular price ~~$149.99 USD~~ Sale price $129.99 USD

Sale

1 6

Authentic Fossilized Shark Teeth -Packed By Hand!-

Who Loves Sharks Teeth? Grab The MOST POPULAR Mystery Bucket here! 😁🦈Want to learn where to find shark teeth in Florida? Read our complete guide here!

Shark Teeth For Sale!

Authentic Hemipristis (Snaggletooth) Shark Tooth

Sold out

Authentic Hemipristis (Snaggletooth) Shark Tooth

Regular price $29.99 USD

Regular price ~~$49.99 USD~~ Sale price $29.99 USD

Sold out
Collector Grade GREAT WHITE Shark Tooth - One of a Kind!

Sold out

Collector Grade GREAT WHITE Shark Tooth - One of a Kind!

Regular price $200.00 USD

Regular price ~~$300.00 USD~~ Sale price $200.00 USD

Sold out
Hemi Snaggletooth Shark Tooth. One-of-a-Kind Fossil Display!

Sold out

Hemi Snaggletooth Shark Tooth. One-of-a-Kind Fossil Display!

Regular price $30.00 USD

Regular price ~~$65.00 USD~~ Sale price $30.00 USD

Sold out
A Whole Great White Shark 🦈

Sold out

A Whole Great White Shark 🦈

Regular price $1,000,000.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1,000,000.00 USD

Sold out

View all

Let customers speak for us

from 19 reviews

Absolutely spectacular gift. Amazing value.

Anonymous

03/01/2026

PREMIUM MEG MYSTERY BUCKET! (32 oz)

Shipping was fast. Enjoyed looking for the teeth.

02/24/2026

Mystery Shark Tooth Bucket (32 oz)

Absolutely love this site! Have purchased 3 different buckets so far and waiting for my 4th! This company has completely surpassed my expectations!! 💙🦈

Michelle

02/22/2026

Relic Reef

Absolutely blown away by the quality of these buckets! 💙🦈

This site is literally the best thing ever! Absolutely hooked! 🦈

HASTALIS MYSTERY BUCKETS! (32oz)

Relic reef has an amazing team with the best quality of customer service. They make it clear they care for their shark tooth loving community.

Ajcoastal

02/16/2026

This shark tooth bucket was more fun than i could have ever imagined! I am 27 years old and haven’t had this much fun since…ever… i found a variety of 50+ teeth in my bucket and wish there was a subscription service for these buckets to be delivered to me on a monthly basis! I love relic reef and can’t wait for my second bucket to arrive!

Thank you for giving us a piece of home from across the country

Haleigh

02/07/2026

MEGALODON MYSTERY BUCKETS! (32oz)

This mystery bucket was everything I hoped for and more!

Gavin Williamson

02/05/2026

Very good.

Rea Holden

01/31/2026

Very surprised and pleased. Going to be a good Christmas present for this year.

Absolutely love it

Adam Clemons

01/24/2026

Awesome vibrant color! Excellent quality shirt! Thank you Relic Reef!

Elveilleux

01/23/2026

I love this shirt! Bright, vibrant color and nice quality! Thank you Relic Reef!

Peace, Love & Shark Teeth Tee

Item added to your cart

Your Own Dig At Home!

Mystery Shark Tooth Bucket (32 oz)

Mystery Shark Tooth Bucket (32 oz)

MEGALODON MYSTERY BUCKETS! (32oz)

MEGALODON MYSTERY BUCKETS! (32oz)

HASTALIS MYSTERY BUCKETS! (32oz)

HASTALIS MYSTERY BUCKETS! (32oz)

Lil’ Chompers Shark Tooth Mystery Bucket - Kids Fossil Discovery Box

Lil’ Chompers Shark Tooth Mystery Bucket - Kids Fossil Discovery Box

PREMIUM MEG MYSTERY BUCKET! (32 oz)

PREMIUM MEG MYSTERY BUCKET! (32 oz)

PREMIUM HASTALIS MYSTERY BUCKET!

PREMIUM HASTALIS MYSTERY BUCKET!

Authentic Fossilized Shark Teeth -Packed By Hand!-

Shark Teeth For Sale!

Authentic Hemipristis (Snaggletooth) Shark Tooth

Authentic Hemipristis (Snaggletooth) Shark Tooth

Collector Grade GREAT WHITE Shark Tooth - One of a Kind!

Collector Grade GREAT WHITE Shark Tooth - One of a Kind!

Hemi Snaggletooth Shark Tooth. One-of-a-Kind Fossil Display!

Hemi Snaggletooth Shark Tooth. One-of-a-Kind Fossil Display!

A Whole Great White Shark 🦈

A Whole Great White Shark 🦈

Customers are saying

Let customers speak for us

Country/region